A Significant Appellate Victory in the Second Department: Interpreting Lien Law § 59 -Congratulations to Chan Vitanza attorneys Virginie M. Brizon, Esq. and Deema K. Hasan, Esq. on their outstanding appellate victory in the Appellate Division Second Department!
The Court affirmed the lower court’s decision, delivering a significant win and contributing to the developing body of New York law interpreting Lien Law § 59. What makes this decision particularly noteworthy is the relative rarity of judicial decisions interpreting Lien Law § 59. Appellate decisions addressing the statute are uncommon, making this ruling especially significant for practitioners handling construction disputes, mechanic’s liens, and related litigation.
Statutory interpretation matters. When courts address provisions that are infrequently litigated or interpreted, their decisions can provide valuable guidance for litigants, counsel, and courts confronting similar issues in the future. This is the kind of appellate work that extends beyond winning an individual case—it helps shape the legal landscape for cases to come.
At Chan Vitanza, we believe in mentoring and guiding our young attorneys, giving them the tools, experience, and support to succeed—and then empowering them to take the lead, make their mark, and achieve results of their own. This victory exemplifies that philosophy.
Congratulations to Virginie and Deema on this well-deserved achievement. Your hard work and legal acumen have resulted in a decision that may be cited for years to come!